---
title: U-haul vs. Penske vs. Budget
description: DeBoer's Auto U-Haul wants YOU to be in the know about your moving and rental needs! Learn more about U-Haul vs The Other Guys
image: https://www.deboersauto.com/hubfs/f29a6b11d3f8ef61d914dc65b64fdddb-2.gif
---

[![KO_DeBoers_Insignia_LOGO_Final_01](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/KO_DeBoers_Insignia_LOGO_Final_01.png?width=282&height=200&name=KO_DeBoers_Insignia_LOGO_Final_01.png)

![Copy of Deboers_LOGO_Final_01-01](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/DeBoers%20Auto%20Logo%202018/Copy%20of%20Deboers_LOGO_Final_01-01.png?width=250&height=144&name=Copy%20of%20Deboers_LOGO_Final_01-01.png) 

](https://www.deboersauto.com/)

[![(973)529-836083 State Route 23 NorthHamburg, NJ 07419](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/354552/9a49b6ea-d33c-4ef3-b93b-8d71b1708c47.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/354552/9a49b6ea-d33c-4ef3-b93b-8d71b1708c47)

[**](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-vs-penske-vs-budget#tmpmodule_1568761248550301)

**

###### 10 min read

# [U-haul vs. Penske vs. Budget](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-vs-penske-vs-budget)

 By [Bill DeBoer](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/author/bill-deboer) on Jun 26, 2017 5:04:37 PM

###### Topics: [Consumer-Friendly](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/topic/consumer-friendly)

![f29a6b11d3f8ef61d914dc65b64fdddb-2.gif](https://www.deboersauto.com/hubfs/f29a6b11d3f8ef61d914dc65b64fdddb-2.gif)

 

 

 

 

 

 

2:49

 

 

 

2:49

 

 

 

- Speed
  
  1x
  
    - 0.5x
    - 1x
    - 1.25x
    - 1.5x
    - 1.75x
    - 2x
- Quality
  
  540p
  
    - Auto
    - 224p
    - 360p
    - 540p
    - 720p
    - 1080p

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

![Wistia video thumbnail - U-haul vs. Penske vs. Budget](https://embedwistia-a.akamaihd.net/deliveries/6549697d1d3e44107ea28777d73891aebc4ed77a.jpg?image_crop_resized=960x540)

[About Wistia](https://wistia.com/about-wistia?about=151315)[Report a problem](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-vs-penske-vs-budget#)[Copy link and thumbnail](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-vs-penske-vs-budget#)

 

Thanks for reporting a problem. We'll attach technical data about this session to help us figure out the issue. Which of these best describes the problem?

Choose one Video plays but frequently stutters Video has poor quality Video fails to play Other

Any other details or context?

 

[Cancel](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-vs-penske-vs-budget#)

Send

message

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

![f29a6b11d3f8ef61d914dc65b64fdddb-2.gif](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/f29a6b11d3f8ef61d914dc65b64fdddb-2.gif?width=320&name=f29a6b11d3f8ef61d914dc65b64fdddb-2.gif)

**U-Haul at your service**, for all your truck and trailer rental needs!

Need to pick which company to rent from? Maybe these quick tips can help!

Let's start with the** truck features**:

| ***U-Haul*** | ***The Other Guys*** |
| --- | --- |
| -offers a low deck for easy access -EZ load ramp is shorter with the low dock height, making the ramp more manageable, sturdy, wider, and is 50% easier to load -The comfortable cab has a low profile and easy entry | -Penske and Budget trucks offer dock height, commonly used for commercial use  -Ramp attachment provided is narrow and wobbly due to higher loading deck height -Cab and seating in a Penske and Budget truck is set up like a high profile freight truck |

![DSCN4278.jpg](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/DSCN4278.jpg?width=324&name=DSCN4278.jpg)

Next, we go over **convenience**:

| ***U-Haul*** ***![truck_lineup_new_rgb_72dpi-2.jpg](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/truck_lineup_new_rgb_72dpi-2.jpg?width=335&height=65&name=truck_lineup_new_rgb_72dpi-2.jpg)*** | U-Haul offers over 15,000 locations in the U.S. and Canada for pickup and dropoff. This helps keep the mileage down on the trucks and saves you some money! U-Haul also provides a wider range of equipment! Truck sizes range from 10 feet to 26 feet in many variations in between. The trailers include EZ load ramps and can come enclosed or open. They carry cargo, cars, utility equipment like lawnmowers. U-Haul offers 9 foot cargo vans, and transportable U-Box storage containers. |
| --- | --- |
| ***The Other Guys*** ***![Hino-Trucks-lineup.jpg](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Hino-Trucks-lineup.jpg?width=291&name=Hino-Trucks-lineup.jpg)*** | Competing companies have about 1,500 locations in the U.S. and Canada. This means you will be driving more to pickup and dropoff, racking up those miles and spending more of your money. The equipment offered with Penske and Budget are not as variant. Truck sizes range from 10 feet to 26 feet in commercial freight style, with not many options in between. They also only offer the standard car trailers, but not trailers that carry cargo and utility equipment.  |

Now, I am sure you are wondering how **other people's experiences** have gone with these companies:

| ***U-Haul*** | ***The Other Guys*** |
| --- | --- |
| Customer reviews have averaged out a score a *4.22 out of 5. ![4-stars.jpg](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/4-stars.jpg?width=119&name=4-stars.jpg)* | Customers have rated competing companies on average about *3.81 out of 5. ![3 star.png](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/3%20star.png?width=85&name=3%20star.png)* |
| U-Haul gives price breaks if, for some reason, your reservation is altered. They have a flexible policy on changes to your reservation made by you. Same-day rental and special offers are provided as well. Plus, there are clear and precise safety features on each U-Haul piece of equipment, and roadside assistance is offered. Also, there are many different options for insurance, including a choice of opting out.  | Competing companies also offer roadside assistance and the occasional same-day rental. Penske and Budget provide promotions and discounts are but, ONLY IF the customer can find them. Safety features are provided on Penske and Budget trucks. And, you are most likely to get your preferred pickup location.  |
| BUT, sometimes U-Haul is not able to provide pickup or dropoff at your chosen and preferred location, due to equipment availability.  | Prices and rates will vary with Penske and Budget based on the deal you find. Reservations are not allowed to be modified online, you must call. Competitors gear their sales more towards commercial use because of the freight styles of the truck. The safety features can be unclear sometimes, and the insurance options are confusing.  |

And lastly, **let's talk number$**: 

| ![careful-moving-co.-clipart.jpg](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/careful-moving-co.-clipart.jpg?width=118&name=careful-moving-co.-clipart.jpg) | **Local Move** *(under 50 miles)* | **Medium Move** *(50-250 miles)* | **Long Move** *(over 250 miles)* |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| ***U-Haul*** | average cost of $120 | average cost of $304 | average cost of $1,068 |
| ***The Other Guys*** | average cost of $181 | average cost of $314 | average cost of $1,194 |

 

Moving this summer?

To learn more and schedule a reservation, call us at DeBoer's Auto U-Haul,

located at 83 State Rt. 23 N in Hamburg, New Jersey

***973-786-3030***

To see more blog posts about U-Haul and our services, [click here](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-moving-hacks-by-movinghelp)!

Click the image below to get started

[![New Call-to-action](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/354552/64a7e485-bfe0-4b26-bdc1-2c116b5674b8.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/354552/64a7e485-bfe0-4b26-bdc1-2c116b5674b8)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

![Bill DeBoer](https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/b794ce60bb0e2a447f9db08a88a1b429)

#### Written by [Bill DeBoer](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/author/bill-deboer)

William J. DeBoer is the Visionary at DeBoer’s Auto. As the company’s CEO, Bill has been responsible for bringing innovations in daily operations to the full-service, high-tech auto repair facility for 20+ years. Passionate about computers from an early age, Bill’s interest in technology gravitated to cars while he was in college. By obtaining a Certificate in Automotive Technology followed by a B.S. in Business Management from Penn State, Bill was able to fuse his interests into a car technology specialization and join the family business shortly thereafter.

[**](https://www.facebook.com/bill.deboer) [**](http://www.linkedin.com/pub/bill-deboer/1a/106/55a) [**](https://twitter.com/DeBoersAuto)

###### [** Previous Post](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-talks-truck-and-trailer-rental-insurance-part-1-of-2)

[![U-Haul-Truck-Rental-Accident-Lawsuits-3.jpg](https://www.deboersauto.com/hubfs/U-Haul-Truck-Rental-Accident-Lawsuits-3.jpg) ](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-talks-truck-and-trailer-rental-insurance-part-1-of-2)

###### [Uhaul Talks Truck and Trailer Rental Insurance: Part 1 of 2](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/uhaul-talks-truck-and-trailer-rental-insurance-part-1-of-2)

###### [Next Post **](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/should-you-buy-truck-and-trailer-rental-insurance)

[![JJ14-20-Lego-Truck.png](https://www.deboersauto.com/hubfs/JJ14-20-Lego-Truck.png) ](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/should-you-buy-truck-and-trailer-rental-insurance)

###### [Should you buy truck and trailer rental insurance?](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/should-you-buy-truck-and-trailer-rental-insurance)

##### DeBoer's Blog

DeBoer's Blog

<https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/the-impact-of-oil-viscosity-on-your-vehicle-in-cold-weather>

###### [The Impact of Oil Viscosity on Your Vehicle in Cold Weather](https://www.deboersauto.com/blog/the-impact-of-oil-viscosity-on-your-vehicle-in-cold-weather)

As winter approaches, it's crucial to consider the effects of oil viscosity on your vehicle's...

##### DeBoer's Auto

DeBoer's Auto

[(973) 529-8360](tel:(973)%20786-3030)

83 State Route 23  
Hamburg, NJ 07419  
Mon - Fri: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

[![AAA Approved Repairs KO](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/AAA_ApprovedRepairs_KO.png?width=107&name=AAA_ApprovedRepairs_KO.png)](https://www.aaa.com/autorepair/)      [![KO ASE Approved](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Edited_KO_ASEApproved.png?width=83&name=Edited_KO_ASEApproved.png)](https://www.ase.com/Home.aspx)

 

[![DeBoer's Auto](https://www.deboersauto.com/hs-fs/hubfs/KO_DeBoers_Insignia_LOGO_Final_01.png?width=175&height=124&name=KO_DeBoers_Insignia_LOGO_Final_01.png "DeBoer's Auto")](https://www.deboersauto.com)

Copyright © 2025 DeBoer's Auto

[**](https://www.facebook.com/deboersauto)[**](https://twitter.com/YourCarGuy)[**](https://www.instagram.com/deboersauto/)[**](https://www.linkedin.com/company/deboers-auto)[**](https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeeHo1Te1vrjdlGCOA0UyMA)

**